I went for substance over glitter for these classics. The gender lines get blurred and the yin yang smudges together for some of the best music produced in the rock era. The glitter and high heels kicking you in the face is the proverbial tip of the iceberg when having a bit of free swim time in this part of the pool. The first couple I added were such strong works that I challenged myself to keep them all of the same quality. This date night went in a different direction than it started, kind of like my number 1 pick for this category.
“What are you doing Mr. Cave guy, this is just a sweet innocent love song by Elton John?” And you are right. Elton John and Bernie Taupin were just sweet innocent kids when they wrote this. The striking part – it is so innocent that it has no male and female parts at all. Like a toy doll with no bits that are going to make the kids ask questions. It has all the sexuality completely sanitized. A man could be singing about a woman- a woman could be singing about a man- it works with a man singing about a man and woman about a woman. It works with any combo deal on the menu.
The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars is one of the great records of rock music and David Bowie became an androgynous alien alter ego for the ages. Maybe some obscure bands were dressing like chicks before he did…but he smashed the doors wide open to let all the cows and horses out of the barn to go play in the fields and roll in the mud. He took it from
a “strange” thing and turned it into an “edgy” thing. The song itself really does not reference any gender blurring but it is impossible to separate the song from the act. You get the package deal with David Bowie.
Me and Bobby McGee- Janis Joplin
Kris Kristofferson wrote this song originally about a woman and in the Janis Joplin version it changed to a man. Even the name Bobby can fit both sexes so it was not a big deal to make a switch. That makes something written from the male perspective get transformed into something from a female perspective. It gives it a weird toughness that Janis Joplin was made to sing.
Angel from Montgomery-Bonnie Raitt
To write this song John Prine imagined himself as a middle aged woman doing dishes and gazing upon the ashes of a burnt-out life. Like an artist that freezes a scene in a painting; he gets all the colors and lines in correct coordination and perfection. I don’t care if you are a woman or a man- this song is powerful. As a man you feel bad about this woman and you should hate the man that drove her down this highway and hope you ain’t him…you should be affected by the emotion if you have anything at all in your soul that feels emotion. This song has a way of making people cry like Ray Lewis in a post game speech after a football game.
“Well, I’m not dumb but I can’t understand Why she walked like a woman but talked like a man”
How in good conscious as a fan of Rock Music do you not make this the Number one song in this category? And just like the naïve soul in this piece of music-How long did it take you to listen to the words and have that “Sixth sense” movie moment…Oh…man…he is a ghost!…I mean..Oh man, he is a transvestite! And how as a regular guy trying to write a music blog do I take so long to get to a song by Ray Davies…the quintessential everyman and icon of popular music…plus he seems like just one hell of a nice guy.
8 thoughts on “Dude looks like a Lady? Not on this list of best 5 Androgyny Rock Interpretations.”
Awesome!!! I might have also added Bowie’s “Queen Bitch” but Ziggy is it! Very cool!
Thanks again, this is all open to interpretation and glad to get visitors that share a passion for this ancient music style called Rock!
I have nominated you for an “Awesome Blog Content (ABC)” Award because, well, you blogged about John Prine. If you’d like to join the fun and play along, check out my nomination post –
Keep up the good work!
Wow…thanks for the nomination! I am truly honored. And I have to admit that black and orange make this award fit very nicely in the cave. I will do my best to fulfill the requirements so I can place this next to the fire at the cave entrance….thank you.
Wonderful. I hadn’t thought of the color coordinating connection. Maybe I should have considered this in the nomination process.. Enjoy.
I appreciate your recognition of Prine’s genius in “Angel from Montgomery”. He is a master story teller.
thanks, it is all about the music
Great article man! Really awesome insight into rock and roll symbolism:P Anyway, cool blog:) Check out mine! Cheers!